Leadership Lessons from the Best & Worst Fictional Bosses

September 1, 2021

Examples of fictional bosses abound on TV, in the movies, and in literature. Many of these leaders demonstrate effective management as they tackle a wide range of challenges. Others aren’t quite so admirable. Still, all provide leadership lessons that can inspire and educate real-world leaders. Below, we highlight both the best and worst of pop culture’s fictional bosses.

Fictional Bosses That Set a Great Example

Many special qualities set fiction’s top bosses apart, but they all seem to hold one key attribute in common: they are deeply authentic. The best of the bunch knows what sets them apart while being keenly aware of their weaknesses — and they own these qualities every day on the job. To that end, they take active steps to learn all they can in order to better themselves. We are especially fond of these skillful leaders:

Captain Raymond Holt: Brooklyn 99

Although he initially seems cold and robotic, Captain Raymond Holt cares deeply about every detective under his supervision. He is well aware of their individual strengths and weaknesses — and he works with these attributes to deliver impressive results. Examples of his encouragement abound, ranging from LGBT employees coming out to tackling with the ramifications of racial profiling. Through all these situations, it’s consistently clear that Captain Holt has his detectives’ backs.

Captain Jean-Luc Picard: Star Trek

Trekkies tend to look to Captain Kirk for inspiration, but Picard is arguably a much better boss. He’s highly empathetic, as evidenced by his willingness to learn the Tamarian language and to get in the faces of the Klingons — a sign of respect in their culture. He’s big on collaboration and capable of leveraging his team’s skills to meet their common goals.

Leslie Knope: Parks and Recreation

Few workplace leaders are as organized or passionate as Leslie Knope. She is one of the most inspiring and likable characters on TV, as she proves that a warm and cheery disposition can prompt effective leadership.

Her thoughtfulness is, perhaps, best exemplified by the care she puts into the personalized gifts she provides for the employees in the parks and recreation department. They certainly notice her hard work and caring attitude — and they repay her by throwing similarly passionate support into her campaign.

Ned Stark: Game of Thrones

While some characters in George R.R. Martin’s world believe that Ned Stark’s insistence on honor and duty compromised the safety of Winterfell and the entirety of Westeros, it could also be argued that his beheading sparked the beginning of the end — precisely because the kingdom he served needed someone so steady and reliable.

Michael Bluth: Arrested Development

In a show full of kooky characters, it can be difficult to believe that anybody might be classified as a desirable boss. Michael Bluth may not be quite as admirable as the other bosses on this list, but his efforts to do the right thing must be commended — especially when you consider that his DNA and his everyday environment are both conspiring against him.

M: James Bond

As the head of MI6, M cultivates a strong working relationship with James Bond. Her simple tastes and no-nonsense attitude set her apart from the womanizing, thrill-seeking main character.

M is not rash, but rather, ponders situations carefully to determine what the wisest course of action might be. In the rare situations in which she is ultimately proven wrong, she’s willing to admit the error of her ways and learn from those mistakes. Similarly, she trusts Bond to do the right thing — or to make amends when he messes up.

Olivia Pope: Scandal

Olivia Pope can be a controversial character at times, but that doesn’t stop her from being an admirable boss. She certainly has plenty of flaws, but there’s no denying her loyalty or ingenuity. She owns up to her mistakes but also knows her worth. A noteworthy bonus: her flawless wardrobe, which reflects her confident attitude.

Jed Bartlet: West Wing

He may be annoyingly smug, but Jed Bartlet has a lot to teach us about effective management. As an authentic leader, he quickly learns to “Let Bartlet be Bartlet.”

President Bartlet’s other chief strength is his insistence on surrounding himself with the best of the best. His advisors consistently bring out his top qualities while also steering him away from his worst impulses. He encourages open and honest conversation with his staffers — and that’s exactly what allows him to excel as president and as a boss.

Learn From the Mistakes of These Bad Bosses

There’s a lot to love about the bosses highlighted above. Sometimes, however, the characters we love to hate are more interesting. There’s nothing quite like a well-written villain to drive a narrative forward. The following bosses range from slightly less than desirable to all-out evil — but all provide valuable leadership lessons worth examining.

Michael Scott: The Office

Michael Scott is a mixed bag as a boss and as a person in general. He has many traits that make him compelling (especially after his rough first season edges are smoothed out), but ultimately, his neediness and constant offensive remarks undermine his loyalty and eagerness to turn his workplace into a family. The Scranton branch succeeds despite — and definitely not because of — his ineffectual leadership.

Darth Vader: Star Wars

As the quintessential villain, Darth Vader shows real-life bosses exactly what not to do. He rules by fear and has no interest whatsoever in building workplace morale. He’s a true micromanager, literally breathing down the necks of his subordinates. Transparency is not a virtue, as far as he’s concerned. Rather, those gutsy enough to tell him the truth can expect to be choked.

Principal Trunchbull: Matilda

Few academic figures are as terrifying as Principal Trunchbull, who remains as frightening to adults rewatching (or rereading) Matilda as she’s always been for the generations of children who loved the book and film. There’s no denying that harsh punishments such as the chokey (and forced eating) are ineffective, but that doesn’t stop Trunchbull from always choosing the stick over the carrot.

Minister Fudge: Harry Potter

He might have a brilliant name, but Cornelius Fudge from the Harry Potter world is the epitome of a weak and ineffective leader. His wishy-washy approach is largely to blame for the second rise of Voldemort. Worse, he suppresses the voices of those who disagree with him, even at the risk of collapsing the wizarding society his cohorts have worked so hard to build.

Mr. Burns: The Simpsons

From blocking out the sun to stealing a trillion-dollar bill, Mr. Burns has terrorized Springfield for years. Yes, he’s provided Homer with a steady income for over three decades but remember: Mr. Burns only hired Homer so that he could fire him later.

Buck Strickland: King of the Hill

Many bosses refuse to promote their assistant managers after years of faithful service. Few, if any, try to frame them for murder after their mistress ends up dead in a dumpster. This surprising turn of events is exactly what makes Buck Strickland so memorable, despite his status as a side character. He consistently passes over 41-time employee of the month Hank Hill for promotions — and he takes advantage of Hank’s loyalty on several occasions.

Don Draper: Mad Men

While viewers tend to romanticize the Don Draper character, he’s a terrible boss. Beyond his obviously sexist behavior, he steals others’ ideas and then basks in the ensuing praise. Truly excellent bosses take pride in their employees’ accomplishments and let them receive due credit when they make positive contributions.

Miranda Priestly: The Devil Wears Prada

Like Michael Scott, Miranda Priestly brings both excellent and terrible qualities to the table. She certainly knows how to deliver results in a cutthroat industry. Unfortunately, in her quest for fashion greatness, she destroys not only her own personal life, but also, those of all her employees. A better boss would make her mark in the fashion world while also showing at least some semblance of support for her hardworking team.

From Leslie Knope to Darth Vader, all fictional bosses can provide helpful leadership lessons. It’s up to us to pay attention. Take a closer look at your favorite works of fiction and you just might come away learning about the meaning of effective management.

If you are interested in learning more about the Business Management degrees offered at Wilmington College Cincinnati, request information today!