| | | Otterbein wins the toss, defers, and will defend the south endzone. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm30 | OTT ball on OTT30. |
| | | Aaric Milligan kickoff 63 yards to the WILM7, Davis-Jackson return 14 yards to the WILM21 (Nick McVay). |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm21 | Kyle Combs rush for no gain to the WILM21 (Chad Pepper;Will Brown). |
| Wilm | 2-10 | at Wilm21 | Brandon Arehart pass complete to Xavier Crocker for 6 yards to the WILM27 (Shane Little;P. Seesholtz). |
| Wilm | 3-4 | at Wilm27 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Malcolm Heard. |
| Wilm | 4-4 | at Wilm27 | Alex Finney punt 13 yards to the WILM40, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 01:42 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Wilm40 | OTTERBEIN UNIVERSITY drive start at 13:18. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Wilm40 | Cody Green rush for 29 yards to the WILM11, 1ST DOWN OTT (R.J. Zygarowski;Devon Burton). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Wilm11 | A. Schlosser rush for loss of 5 yards to the WILM16, fumble by A. Schlosser recovered by WILM Devon Burton at WILM13. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 27 yards, TOP 00:30 |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm13 | WILMINGTON COLLEGE drive start at 12:48. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm13 | Brandon Arehart pass complete to Kyle Combs for 8 yards to the WILM21 (Shane Little). |
| Wilm | 2-2 | at Wilm21 | Brandon Arehart pass complete to Xavier Crocker for 12 yards to the WILM33, 1ST DOWN WILM (Wes McKeever;Matt Ross). |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm33 | Kyle Combs rush for 10 yards to the WILM43, 1ST DOWN WILM (Will Brown). |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm43 | Brandon Arehart pass complete to Kyle Akers for 2 yards to the WILM45, out-of-bounds (Jordan Benson), PENALTY WILM holding 10 yards to the WILM35. |
| Wilm | 1-18 | at Wilm35 | 1st and 18. |
| Wilm | 1-18 | at Wilm35 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Malcolm Heard (Jordan Benson). |
| Wilm | 2-18 | at Wilm35 | Kyle Combs rush for 2 yards to the WILM37 (Josh McCaskey). |
| Wilm | 3-16 | at Wilm37 | Brandon Arehart rush for 3 yards to the WILM40 (Will Brown;Shane Little). |
| Wilm | 4-13 | at Wilm40 | Alex Finney punt 31 yards to the OTT29, downed. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 27 yards, TOP 04:00 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott29 | OTTERBEIN UNIVERSITY drive start at 08:48. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott29 | Cody Green rush for 3 yards to the OTT32 (Darian McGee). |
| Ott | 2-7 | at Ott32 | PENALTY OTT false start (Grant Smith) 5 yards to the OTT27. |
| Ott | 2-12 | at Ott27 | A. Schlosser pass complete to Cody Green for 6 yards to the OTT33 (Ben Dunahue). |
| Ott | 3-6 | at Ott33 | A. Schlosser pass complete to S. Carpenter for 17 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN OTT (A. Shelton). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott50 | Cody Green rush for 3 yards to the WILM47 (A. Shelton). |
| Ott | 2-7 | at Wilm47 | S. Carpenter rush for 35 yards to the WILM12, 1ST DOWN OTT (Matt McFadden). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Wilm12 | A. Schlosser pass complete to Gabe Shively for 12 yards to the WILM0, 1ST DOWN OTT, TOUCHDOWN, clock 05:52, PENALTY WILM Encroachment declined. |
| | | Aaric Milligan kick attempt good. |
| | | Otterbein University 7, Wilmington College 0 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 71 yards, TOP 02:56 |
| | | Aaric Milligan kickoff 70 yards to the WILM0, touchback. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm20 | WILMINGTON COLLEGE drive start at 05:52. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm20 | Brandon Arehart rush for 2 yards to the WILM22, out-of-bounds (Jordan Benson). |
| Wilm | 2-8 | at Wilm22 | Ryan Smith rush for loss of 2 yards to the WILM20 (P. Seesholtz). |
| Wilm | 3-10 | at Wilm20 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Malcolm Heard (Jordan Benson). |
| Wilm | 4-10 | at Wilm20 | Alex Finney punt 26 yards to the WILM46, A. Korpieski return 10 yards to the WILM36, out-of-bounds (Andy Apking). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 01:34 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Wilm36 | OTTERBEIN UNIVERSITY drive start at 04:18. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Wilm36 | Brock Burzanko pass incomplete to Trey Fairchild. |
| Ott | 2-10 | at Wilm36 | A. Schlosser pass complete to Trey Fairchild for 30 yards to the WILM6, 1ST DOWN OTT (LaVonte' Darby). |
| Ott | 1-G | at Wilm06 | Cody Green rush for 4 yards to the WILM2 (A. Shelton;Donnie Ary). |
| Ott | 2-G | at Wilm02 | A. Schlosser rush for 2 yards to the WILM0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 02:49. |
| | | Aaric Milligan kick attempt failed. |
| | | Otterbein University 13, Wilmington College 0 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 36 yards, TOP 01:29 |
| | | Aaric Milligan kickoff 70 yards to the WILM0, touchback. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm20 | WILMINGTON COLLEGE drive start at 02:49. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm20 | Ryan Smith rush for 1 yard to the WILM21 (Will Brown). |
| Wilm | 2-9 | at Wilm21 | Ryan Smith rush for loss of 1 yard to the WILM20 (Eric Mitchell). |
| Wilm | 3-10 | at Wilm20 | Brandon Arehart pass complete to Malcolm Heard for 15 yards to the WILM35, 1ST DOWN WILM (Matt Ross;Rocco Pentello). |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm35 | Ryan Smith rush for 2 yards to the WILM37 (Eric Mitchell). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 17 yards, TOP 03:43 |
| | | Otterbein University 13, Wilmington College 0 |
| Wilm | 2-8 | at Wilm37 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Wilm | 2-8 | at Wilm37 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Daryl Howard, QB hurry by Will Brown. |
| Wilm | 3-8 | at Wilm37 | Brandon Arehart pass complete to Ryan Smith for 4 yards to the WILM41 (A. Korpieski). |
| Wilm | 4-4 | at Wilm41 | Brandon Arehart punt 59 yards to the OTT0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 21 yards, TOP 03:43 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott20 | OTTERBEIN UNIVERSITY drive start at 14:06. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott20 | A. Schlosser pass incomplete to Trey Fairchild (Joe Joe Knecht). |
| Ott | 2-10 | at Ott20 | A. Schlosser rush for 15 yards to the OTT35, 1ST DOWN OTT (Devon Burton). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott35 | Cody Green rush for loss of 7 yards to the OTT28, fumble by Cody Green recovered by WILM Aaron Day at OTT27. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 7 yards, TOP 00:48 |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Ott27 | WILMINGTON COLLEGE drive start at 13:18. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Ott27 | Brandon Arehart pass complete to Malcolm Heard for 8 yards to the OTT19 (Jordan Benson). |
| Wilm | 2-2 | at Ott19 | Brandon Arehart pass complete to Matt Stooksbury for 3 yards to the OTT16, 1ST DOWN WILM (A. Korpieski). |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Ott16 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Xavier Crocker (P. Seesholtz). |
| Wilm | 2-10 | at Ott16 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Malcolm Heard, PENALTY OTT pass interference (Jordan Benson) 14 yards to the OTT2, 1ST DOWN WILM, NO PLAY. |
| Wilm | 1-G | at Ott02 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Malcolm Heard. |
| Wilm | 2-G | at Ott02 | Brandon Arehart rush for 2 yards to the OTT0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:39. |
| | | Max Gabbard kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by Harlan Page), NO PLAY, PENALTY OTT Encroachment 1 yards to the OTT2, NO PLAY. |
| | | Max Gabbard kick attempt good. |
| | | Otterbein University 13, Wilmington College 7 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 27 yards, TOP 01:53 |
| | | A. Kleinhans kickoff 69 yards to the OTT1, Trey Fairchild return 28 yards to the OTT29 (Ryan Smith), PENALTY WILM offside 5 yards to the OTT34, 1st and 10, OTT ball on OTT34. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott34 | OTTERBEIN UNIVERSITY drive start at 11:25. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott34 | Cody Green rush for 4 yards to the OTT38 (Donnie Ary). |
| Ott | 2-6 | at Ott38 | A. Schlosser pass complete to Trey Fairchild for 4 yards to the OTT42 (Joe Joe Knecht). |
| Ott | 3-2 | at Ott42 | A. Schlosser pass incomplete to Gabe Shively. |
| Ott | 4-2 | at Ott42 | Aaron Kingcade punt 17 yards to the WILM41, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 8 yards, TOP 01:38 |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm41 | WILMINGTON COLLEGE drive start at 09:47. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm41 | Brandon Arehart pass complete to Malcolm Heard for 1 yard to the WILM42 (Chad Pepper). |
| Wilm | 2-9 | at Wilm42 | Brandon Arehart pass complete to Kyle Combs for 5 yards to the WILM47 (Eric Mitchell). |
| Wilm | 3-4 | at Wilm47 | Brandon Arehart sacked for loss of 13 yards to the WILM34 (Will Brown). |
| Wilm | 4-17 | at Wilm34 | Alex Finney punt 39 yards to the OTT27, A. Korpieski return 55 yards to the WILM18 (Alex Finney). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 7 yards, TOP 02:27 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Wilm18 | OTTERBEIN UNIVERSITY drive start at 07:20. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Wilm18 | Cody Green rush for 2 yards to the WILM16 (Darian McGee). |
| Ott | 2-8 | at Wilm16 | Cody Green rush for 7 yards to the WILM9 (Darian McGee). |
| Ott | 3-1 | at Wilm09 | Cody Green rush for 5 yards to the WILM4, 1ST DOWN OTT (Steth Jackson). |
| Ott | 1-G | at Wilm04 | Cody Green rush for 4 yards to the WILM0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 05:10. |
| Ott | 1-G | at Wilm03 | Timeout Otterbein University, clock 05:10. |
| | | A. Schlosser pass attempt failed. |
| | | Otterbein University 19, Wilmington College 7 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 18 yards, TOP 02:17 |
| | | Aaric Milligan kickoff 57 yards to the WILM13, Davis-Jackson return 15 yards to the WILM28 (Nate Bucci). |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm28 | WILMINGTON COLLEGE drive start at 05:03. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm28 | Ryan Smith rush for 6 yards to the WILM34 (Chad Pepper), PENALTY OTT face mask 15 yards to the WILM49, 1ST DOWN WILM. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm49 | 1st and 10. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm49 | Ryan Smith rush for loss of 2 yards to the WILM47 (P. Seesholtz). |
| Wilm | 2-12 | at Wilm47 | Brandon Arehart pass complete to Brett McEvoy for 24 yards to the OTT29, 1ST DOWN WILM (A. Korpieski;Shane Little). |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Ott29 | Brandon Arehart pass complete to Malcolm Heard for 10 yards to the OTT19, 1ST DOWN WILM (Chad Pepper). |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Ott19 | Brandon Arehart pass complete to Ryan Smith for 8 yards to the OTT11 (Chad Pepper). |
| Wilm | 2-2 | at Ott11 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to A. Shelton, QB hurry by Shane Little. |
| Wilm | 3-2 | at Ott11 | Brandon Arehart rush for 10 yards to the OTT1, fumble forced by Team, fumble by Brandon Arehart recovered by OTT Rocco Pentello at OTT0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 72 yards, TOP 02:59 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott20 | OTTERBEIN UNIVERSITY drive start at 02:04. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott20 | A. Schlosser pass complete to Chris Irwin for 23 yards to the OTT43, 1ST DOWN OTT (Matt McFadden). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott43 | A. Schlosser pass complete to Trey Fairchild for 4 yards to the OTT47 (Darian McGee), PENALTY OTT holding 10 yards to the OTT37. |
| Ott | 1-16 | at Ott37 | 1st and 16. |
| Ott | 1-16 | at Ott37 | A. Schlosser rush for loss of 2 yards to the OTT35, out-of-bounds (Darian McGee). |
| Ott | 2-18 | at Ott35 | A. Schlosser pass complete to S. Carpenter for 11 yards to the OTT46 (Devon Burton). |
| Ott | 3-7 | at Ott46 | Timeout Wilmington College, clock 01:10. |
| Ott | 3-7 | at Ott46 | A. Schlosser pass intercepted by Joe Joe Knecht at the WILM30, Joe Joe Knecht return 1 yards to the WILM31 (Trey Fairchild). |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 26 yards, TOP 01:01 |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm31 | WILMINGTON COLLEGE drive start at 01:03. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm31 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Malcolm Heard. |
| Wilm | 2-10 | at Wilm31 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Kyle Akers. |
| Wilm | 3-10 | at Wilm31 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Kyle Akers. |
| Wilm | 4-10 | at Wilm31 | Brandon Arehart punt 33 yards to the OTT36, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:25 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott36 | OTTERBEIN UNIVERSITY drive start at 00:38. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott36 | A. Schlosser rush for 5 yards to the OTT41, out-of-bounds (A. Shelton), PENALTY WILM personal foul (A. Shelton) 15 yards to the WILM44, 1ST DOWN OTT. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Wilm44 | 1st and 10. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Wilm44 | A. Schlosser sacked for loss of 6 yards to the 50 yardline (A. Shelton). |
| Ott | 2-16 | at Ott50 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 14 yards, TOP 00:38 |
| | | Otterbein University 19, Wilmington College 7 |
| Ott | 2-16 | at Ott50 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Ott | 2-16 | at Ott50 | WILM ball on WILM30. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 14 yards, TOP 00:38 |
| | | A. Kleinhans kickoff 50 yards to the OTT20, S. Carpenter return 1 yards to the OTT21 (Kyle Combs). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott21 | OTTERBEIN UNIVERSITY drive start at 14:52. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott21 | Cody Green rush for 4 yards to the OTT25 (Aaron Day). |
| Ott | 2-6 | at Ott25 | Cody Green rush for 7 yards to the OTT32, 1ST DOWN OTT (Aaron Day). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott32 | Cody Green rush for loss of 2 yards to the OTT30 (Devon Burton). |
| Ott | 2-12 | at Ott30 | A. Schlosser pass complete to Grant Smith for loss of 1 yard to the OTT29 (LaVonte' Darby). |
| Ott | 3-13 | at Ott29 | S. Carpenter rush for 12 yards to the OTT41, fumble by S. Carpenter recovered by WILM Devon Burton at OTT43. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 22 yards, TOP 02:28 |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Ott43 | WILMINGTON COLLEGE drive start at 12:24. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Ott43 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Kyle Akers (S. Brintlinger). |
| Wilm | 2-10 | at Ott43 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Kyle Akers (Jordan Benson). |
| Wilm | 3-10 | at Ott43 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Kyle Akers, QB hurry by Will Brown. |
| Wilm | 4-10 | at Ott43 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Daryl Howard. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:19 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott43 | OTTERBEIN UNIVERSITY drive start at 12:05. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott43 | A. Schlosser pass complete to Trey Fairchild for 45 yards to the WILM12, 1ST DOWN OTT (LaVonte' Darby), PENALTY WILM offside declined. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Wilm12 | Cody Green rush for 9 yards to the WILM3 (A. Shelton). |
| Ott | 2-1 | at Wilm03 | Cody Green rush for 3 yards to the WILM0, 1ST DOWN OTT, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:49. |
| | | Aaric Milligan kick attempt good. |
| | | Otterbein University 26, Wilmington College 7 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 57 yards, TOP 01:20 |
| | | Aaric Milligan kickoff 56 yards to the WILM14, Davis-Jackson return 6 yards to the WILM20 (Wes McKeever). |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm20 | WILMINGTON COLLEGE drive start at 10:45. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm20 | Brandon Arehart pass complete to Matt Stooksbury for 20 yards to the WILM40, 1ST DOWN WILM. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm40 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Daryl Howard (Jordan Benson). |
| Wilm | 2-10 | at Wilm40 | Brandon Arehart rush for no gain to the WILM40 (Will Brown). |
| Wilm | 3-10 | at Wilm40 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Malcolm Heard (Jordan Benson). |
| Wilm | 4-10 | at Wilm40 | Brandon Arehart punt 37 yards to the OTT23, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 20 yards, TOP 01:34 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott23 | OTTERBEIN UNIVERSITY drive start at 09:11. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott23 | Brit Musal rush for no gain to the OTT23 (Matt McFadden), PENALTY WILM personal foul (Donnie Ary) 15 yards to the OTT38, 1ST DOWN OTT. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott38 | Brit Musal rush for 1 yard to the OTT39 (Darian McGee). |
| Ott | 2-9 | at Ott39 | A. Schlosser pass complete to Gabe Shively for 19 yards to the WILM42, 1ST DOWN OTT (Joe Joe Knecht). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Wilm42 | S. Carpenter rush for 8 yards to the WILM34 (Donnie Ary;Matt McFadden). |
| Ott | 2-2 | at Wilm34 | Brit Musal rush for 14 yards to the WILM20, 1ST DOWN OTT (LaVonte' Darby). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Wilm20 | Brit Musal rush for 6 yards to the WILM14 (Ben Dunahue;Joe Joe Knecht). |
| Ott | 2-4 | at Wilm14 | Brit Musal rush for 7 yards to the WILM7, 1ST DOWN OTT (A. Shelton;Devon Burton). |
| Ott | 1-G | at Wilm07 | Brit Musal rush for 2 yards to the WILM5 (A. Shelton;Ben Dunahue). |
| Ott | 2-G | at Wilm05 | Brit Musal rush for 3 yards to the WILM2 (A. Shelton;Donnie Ary). |
| Ott | 3-G | at Wilm02 | Brit Musal rush for 1 yard to the WILM1 (A. Shelton). |
| Ott | 4-G | at Wilm01 | Timeout Wilmington College, clock 03:14. |
| Ott | 4-G | at Wilm01 | Brit Musal rush for 1 yard to the WILM0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 03:12. |
| | | Aaric Milligan kick attempt good. |
| | | Otterbein University 33, Wilmington College 7 |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 77 yards, TOP 06:03 |
| | | Aaric Milligan kickoff 51 yards to the WILM19, Brett McEvoy return 10 yards to the WILM29 (Nate Bucci). |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm29 | WILMINGTON COLLEGE drive start at 03:08. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm29 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Kyle Akers. |
| Wilm | 2-10 | at Wilm29 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Kyle Akers. |
| Wilm | 3-10 | at Wilm29 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Kyle Akers. |
| Wilm | 4-10 | at Wilm29 | Alex Finney punt 34 yards to the OTT37, A. Korpieski return 22 yards to the WILM41. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:36 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Wilm41 | OTTERBEIN UNIVERSITY drive start at 02:32. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Wilm41 | Aaron Kingcade pass incomplete to S. Carpenter. |
| Ott | 2-10 | at Wilm41 | Aaron Kingcade pass complete to S. Carpenter for 4 yards to the WILM37. |
| Ott | 3-6 | at Wilm37 | Aaron Kingcade pass incomplete to Brock Burzanko. |
| Ott | 4-6 | at Wilm37 | Aaron Kingcade pass incomplete to Nick McVay (A. Shelton). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 4 yards, TOP 00:59 |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm37 | WILMINGTON COLLEGE drive start at 01:33. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm37 | Ryan Smith rush for 7 yards to the WILM44 (Shayne Willis). |
| Wilm | 2-3 | at Wilm44 | Ryan Smith rush for 7 yards to the OTT49, 1ST DOWN WILM (Shayne Willis). |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Ott49 | Ryan Smith rush for 4 yards to the OTT45 (Will Brown). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 18 yards, TOP 03:44 |
| | | Otterbein University 33, Wilmington College 7 |
| Wilm | 2-6 | at Ott45 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Wilm | 2-6 | at Ott45 | Brandon Arehart rush for 6 yards to the OTT39, 1ST DOWN WILM (Nate Bucci). |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Ott39 | Ryan Smith rush for no gain to the OTT39 (Eric Mitchell). |
| Wilm | 2-10 | at Ott39 | Brandon Arehart pass complete to Malcolm Heard for 6 yards to the OTT33 (A. Korpieski). |
| Wilm | 3-4 | at Ott33 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Kyle Akers. |
| Wilm | 4-4 | at Ott33 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Xavier Jordan. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 30 yards, TOP 03:44 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott33 | OTTERBEIN UNIVERSITY drive start at 12:49. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott33 | Brock Burzanko rush for 3 yards to the OTT36 (Donnie Ary). |
| Ott | 2-7 | at Ott36 | PENALTY OTT substitution infraction 5 yards to the OTT31. |
| Ott | 2-12 | at Ott31 | Brock Burzanko rush for 6 yards to the OTT37, out-of-bounds (Matt McFadden). |
| Ott | 3-6 | at Ott37 | Aaron Kingcade pass complete to Trey Fairchild for 31 yards to the WILM32, 1ST DOWN OTT (LaVonte' Darby). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Wilm32 | Aaron Kingcade rush for loss of 1 yard to the WILM33, fumble by Aaron Kingcade recovered by WILM Donnie Ary at WILM33. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 34 yards, TOP 02:13 |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm33 | WILMINGTON COLLEGE drive start at 10:36. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm33 | Brandon Arehart pass incomplete to Garret Marsh. |
| Wilm | 2-10 | at Wilm33 | Brandon Arehart pass complete to Malcolm Heard for 14 yards to the WILM47, 1ST DOWN WILM (Nate Bucci). |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm47 | Brandon Arehart rush for 13 yards to the OTT40, 1ST DOWN WILM, out-of-bounds. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Ott40 | Brandon Arehart pass complete to Brett McEvoy for 14 yards to the OTT26, 1ST DOWN WILM, out-of-bounds. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Ott26 | Brandon Arehart pass complete to Kyle Akers for 26 yards to the OTT0, 1ST DOWN WILM, TOUCHDOWN, clock 08:52, PENALTY OTT offside declined. |
| | | Max Gabbard kick attempt good. |
| | | Otterbein University 33, Wilmington College 14 |
| | | A. Kleinhans kickoff 42 yards to the OTT28, out-of-bounds, PENALTY WILM illegal procedure off-setting, PENALTY OTT personal foul off-setting, NO PLAY. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 67 yards, TOP 01:50 |
| | | A. Kleinhans kickoff 27 yards to the OTT43, Brit Musal return 0 yards to the OTT43 (Brett McEvoy). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott43 | OTTERBEIN UNIVERSITY drive start at 08:46. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott43 | Brock Burzanko rush for no gain to the OTT43 (A. Shelton). |
| Ott | 2-10 | at Ott43 | Aaron Kingcade rush for 13 yards to the WILM44, 1ST DOWN OTT (A. Shelton). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Wilm44 | Aaron Kingcade pass complete to Brock Burzanko for 18 yards to the WILM26, 1ST DOWN OTT (A. Shelton). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Wilm26 | PENALTY OTT substitution infraction 5 yards to the WILM31. |
| Ott | 1-15 | at Wilm31 | Brock Burzanko rush for 1 yard to the WILM30 (Devon Burton). |
| Ott | 2-14 | at Wilm30 | Aaron Kingcade pass complete to Gabe Shively for 14 yards to the WILM16, 1ST DOWN OTT (A. Shelton;Matt McFadden). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Wilm16 | Aaron Kingcade rush for 2 yards to the WILM14 (Donnie Ary). |
| Ott | 2-8 | at Wilm14 | Brock Burzanko rush for 6 yards to the WILM8 (Darian McGee). |
| Ott | 3-2 | at Wilm08 | Brock Burzanko rush for 8 yards to the WILM0, 1ST DOWN OTT, TOUCHDOWN, clock 03:53. |
| | | Aaric Milligan kick attempt good. |
| | | Otterbein University 40, Wilmington College 14 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 57 yards, TOP 04:53 |
| | | Aaric Milligan kickoff 70 yards to the WILM0, touchback. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm20 | WILMINGTON COLLEGE drive start at 03:53. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm20 | Nate Stierhoff pass complete to Malcolm Heard for 30 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN WILM (Wade D'Andrea). |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm50 | Nate Stierhoff pass incomplete to Daryl Howard (Michael Angle). |
| Wilm | 2-10 | at Wilm50 | Kyle Combs rush for 15 yards to the OTT35, fumble forced by Kevin Castle, fumble by Kyle Combs recovered by OTT Team at OTT33. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 47 yards, TOP 00:35 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott33 | OTTERBEIN UNIVERSITY drive start at 03:18. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott33 | Brock Burzanko rush for 1 yard to the OTT34 (Steth Jackson). |
| Ott | 2-9 | at Ott34 | Brock Burzanko rush for 2 yards to the OTT36 (Donnie Ary). |
| Ott | 3-7 | at Ott36 | Aaron Kingcade pass incomplete to S. Carpenter. |
| Ott | 4-7 | at Ott36 | Aaron Kingcade punt 64 yards to the WILM0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 3 yards, TOP 01:30 |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm20 | WILMINGTON COLLEGE drive start at 01:48. |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm20 | Nate Stierhoff pass complete to Brett McEvoy for 25 yards to the WILM45, 1ST DOWN WILM (Kevin Castle). |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Wilm45 | Nate Stierhoff pass complete to Malcolm Heard for loss of 5 yards to the WILM40 (A. Lovelace). |
| Wilm | 2-15 | at Wilm40 | Timeout Wilmington College, clock 01:14. |
| Wilm | 2-15 | at Wilm40 | Nate Stierhoff pass complete to Xavier Jordan for 7 yards to the WILM47 (Kevin Castle). |
| Wilm | 3-8 | at Wilm47 | Nate Stierhoff pass complete to Xavier Jordan for 7 yards to the OTT46 (Kevin Castle). |
| Wilm | 4-1 | at Ott46 | Timeout Wilmington College, clock 00:38. |
| Wilm | 4-1 | at Ott46 | Kyle Combs rush for 2 yards to the OTT44, 1ST DOWN WILM (Alex Cameron). |
| Wilm | 1-10 | at Ott44 | Nate Stierhoff pass incomplete to Malcolm Heard (Alex Cameron). |
| Wilm | 2-10 | at Ott44 | Nate Stierhoff pass intercepted by Alex Cameron at the OTT18, Alex Cameron return -4 yards to the OTT14 (Malcolm Heard). |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 36 yards, TOP 01:36 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott14 | OTTERBEIN UNIVERSITY drive start at 00:12. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott14 | Team rush for loss of 1 yard to the OTT13. |
| Ott | 2-11 | at Ott13 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 00:12 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Otterbein University 40, Wilmington College 14 |